01 · Why HalfTime exists
Rs 1,000.Two years.
In 2011, members of the legal aid committee at National Law University, Delhi found a 22-year-old in Tihar jail. He came from a village near Aligarh. He had been held there for about two years as an undertrial.[1]
He was accused of stealing a wallet and of being a wrongful receiver of stolen goods: Rs 1,000 in all. Bail was Rs 10,000. He could not furnish it.
The students arranged a settlement with the alleged victim. The magistrate compounded the case, and he was released on a surety bond.
Our arithmetic, not the report's
- Charge
- Maximum
- Theft, IPC 379
- 36 months
- Stolen goods, IPC 411
- 36 months
- Half of 36 months
- 18 months
- Held, about
- 24 months
Theft and dishonestly receiving stolen property each carry at most three years.[2] The half line was already law: Section 436A of the CrPC, in force since June 2006.[3]
He was found because students went looking. HalfTime exists so that finding the next person past the line does not depend on that.
02 · The scale, 2024
It is not one case.
National Crime Records Bureau figures for the end of 2024, the first year Section 479 was in force.
- undertrials in India's prisons at the end of 2024
- 3,71,440[4] NCRB, Prison Statistics India 2024 (as reported by Daily Excelsior)
- of everyone in prison had not been convicted
- 72.6%[4] NCRB, Prison Statistics India 2024 (as reported by Daily Excelsior)
- occupancy: more people than the prisons were built for
- 112.7%[4] NCRB, Prison Statistics India 2024 (as reported by Daily Excelsior)
- undertrials held for more than two years
- 60,130[5] NCRB, Prison Statistics India 2024, Table 7.4 (as cited in a Research Square preprint)
- held for more than five years
- 9,028[5] NCRB, Prison Statistics India 2024, Table 7.4 (as cited in a Research Square preprint)
And under the new law, in a year
Against 60,130 people held for more than two years, these are the Section 479 counts for the whole of 2024.
people identified under Section 479 in 2024
[5] NCRB, Prison Statistics India 2024, Table 7.4 (as cited in a Research Square preprint)applications filed
[5] NCRB, Prison Statistics India 2024, Table 7.4 (as cited in a Research Square preprint)released
[5] NCRB, Prison Statistics India 2024, Table 7.4 (as cited in a Research Square preprint)
03 · The law over time
The line has been law since 2006.
What changed in 2024 is who must act. The jail now has a written duty to apply.
Section 479, plainly23 Jun 2006
Section 436A, Code of Criminal Procedure
Added by Act 25 of 2005, in force from this date. An undertrial detained for up to one-half of the maximum term for the offence is to be released by the court on a personal bond. Offences punishable with death are outside it, and no one may be held for longer than the maximum term itself.
9 Jun 2011
A Rs 1,000 case, two years in Tihar
The case at the top of this page is reported. The half line had been law for five years.
1 Jul 2024
The BNSS replaces the CrPC. Section 479 takes over from 436A.
The half line stays. A first-time offender's line is one-third of the maximum. And Section 479(3) puts the duty on the jail: on completion of that period, the superintendent shall forthwith apply in writing to the court.
23 Aug 2024
The Supreme Court applies 479 to older cases
Section 479 applies to undertrials in cases registered before 1 July 2024 too. Jail superintendents are directed to move the applications through the courts, preferably within three months.
2024
968 identified. 467 applications.
For the whole country, in the first year of the new law, against 3,71,440 undertrials.
04 · Who it is for
Built for the people who already have the duty.
- 01
Sweep
A jail's papers in. Every order read, every quote checked.
- 02
Flagged list
Each person sorted by the law, with the reason on the card.
- 03
479(3) draft
The application, for a lawyer to check and sign.
Legal-aid panel lawyers
Sweep a jail's papers and start the week from a list of who is past the line, each with the quote that puts them there.
District Legal Services Authorities
One sweep before each jail visit, so legal-aid time goes first to the people already past the line.
Jail superintendents
Section 479(3) makes the application their duty. HalfTime drafts it, ready for a lawyer to check and sign.
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, Section 479 (bare act)Undertrial Review Committees
Bring a flagged list to the review, with every 479(2) case marked for a lawyer rather than decided.
These are the people HalfTime is built for. None of them uses it yet; a pilot comes next.
05 · What it will never do
It finds. A court decides.
- It never releases anyone or tells a court what to do. It drafts paperwork for a lawyer to sign.
- It never settles a 479(2) question. Those cases are flagged for a lawyer.
- It never guesses a maximum term it cannot source. It says “can't tell”.
Next
- 01 · PilotOne District Legal Services Authority, one jail, a sweep before each visit.
- 02 · Real ordersHeld-out real bail orders on the proof page, in place of constructed ones.
- 03 · The registere-Prisons data, so a sweep starts from the jail's own list of who is inside.
Sources
- [1]Legally India, 9 Jun 2011: NLU Delhi legal aiders free Tihar undertrial accused of Rs 1,000 theft
- [2]Indian Penal Code, 1860, Chapter XVII: Sections 379 and 411 (bare act text)
- [3]Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, Section 436A, inserted by Act 25 of 2005, s. 36, w.e.f. 23 Jun 2006 (Indian Kanoon)
- [4]NCRB, Prison Statistics India 2024 (as reported by Daily Excelsior)
- [5]NCRB, Prison Statistics India 2024, Table 7.4 (as cited in a Research Square preprint)
- [6]LiveLaw, 24 Feb 2024: new criminal laws, including the BNSS, to come into force from 1 July 2024
- [7]Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, Section 479 (bare act)
- [8]Supreme Court, In Re: Inhuman Conditions in 1382 Prisons, W.P.(C) 406/2013, order of 23 Aug 2024 (LiveLaw report)
The arithmetic in the opening is ours, from the maximum terms in [2]; the 2011 report does not make it. The person in that report is not named here. This page is not legal advice.