Same order · same model · different method

A chatbot answers. HalfTime shows its working.

Chatbot says

Eligible from 14 Mar 2024

HalfTime says

Past the line · flagged

Answer key (constructed)

Past the line · flagged

Chatbot: Says eligible but misses Sec 479(2): more than one offence or other cases.

Plain chatbot

Prompt: “Read this court order. Is the accused eligible for release under Section 479 of the BNSS? If yes, from what date? Answer in one paragraph.”

Yes, on the facts in the order, the accused appears eligible for release under Section 479 BNSS. The offences are Sections 379 and 411 IPC, each punishable with at most 3 years' imprisonment, and neither carries death or life imprisonment, so the Section 479 bar does not apply. The order records that he has no criminal history, which makes him a first-time offender, so he qualifies after serving one-third of the maximum sentence, i.e. 1 year. He has been in custody since 14.03.2023, so he crossed that threshold on 14.03.2024. Even the general half-term threshold of 1.5 years was crossed on 14.09.2024. Because BNSS took effect only on 01.07.2024, his entitlement strictly arises from 01.07.2024. The Supreme Court has held that Section 479 applies to all undertrial prisoners in pending cases, whenever the offence was registered. By the order date of 28.10.2026 he had been in custody for over 3 years 7 months, longer than the maximum 3-year sentence for either offence. The order does not mention Section 479 at all and rejects bail only on the "gravity of the offence", which looks like an oversight. This assumes he has no other pending cases against him and that he caused no delay in the trial that would be excluded from the computation, and the order records neither. Subject to that, he should be released on his personal bond, with the jail superintendent or the court acting on it, and a fresh application invoking Section 479 should be filed.

No quotes. No checks. Nothing a lawyer can verify line by line.

HalfTime

  1. IPC 1860 s.379 (Punishment for theft) → max 3 years
  2. IPC 1860 s.411 (Dishonestly receiving stolen property) → max 3 years
  3. Case from before 1 Jul 2024: Sec 479 BNSS still applies, per the Supreme Court order of 23 Aug 2024. Old Sec 436A CrPC (half line, no first-time benefit) shown for comparison.
  4. Longest maximum among the charges: 3 years (IPC 1860 s.379).
  5. First-time offender (per the papers): one-third of 3 years.
  6. Custody began 14 Mar 2023.
  7. Line: 14 Mar 2024.
  8. Today: 13 Nov 2026; 1340 days detained.
  9. Detention has reached the full maximum term.
  10. Sec 479(2): More than one offence is charged (IPC 1860 s.379, IPC 1860 s.411).
  11. PAST THE LINE by 974 days, FLAGGED under Sec 479(2): a lawyer decides how 479(2) applies before the application.
Open the case with the papers and quotes